I’ve recently gotten into I Wanna Be the Guy fangames. This is an interesting, ironic development. Why? Because I wasn’t a fan of the original I Wanna Be the Guy for the longest time.
From memory, I first played it at MAGFest VI (I went to MAGFests before they were named by year cool!). For those familiar with the game, I got to the first apple giant cherry delicious fruit falling up and killing me, and decided that was enough for me. Yes, this is one of the first screens of the game. No, I did not care.
Later, I watched some Let’s Plays of it, as I imagine basically everyone my age on the Internet at the time did. The game was a big deal, and it spawned a whole host of fangames of varying difficulty and faithfulness to the original game.
And so, inspired by FlannelKat, I started to dip into the world of IWBTG fangames. And it turns out there are a lot. More than I can easily curate. I played a few of the games on this page, including playing “I Wanna Challenge 100 Trials!” on my stream. From there, Sethdash on Twitch pointed me at the Fangame Skill Rating Spreadsheet, a listing of various fangames organized by difficulty.
It’s taken a bit, but I’ve now played through everything in the Bronze tier of the first two of the spreadsheet. That’s 26 fangames, for the record. What follows are thoughts on some games that stood out to me for whatever reason. This isn’t necessarily a “Best of the Bronze Tier” list, though I’d say the whole tier is worth playing to varying degrees (The nice thing about this list is that, being curated, a given game should at minimum offer “a competently executed experience”.). These are ones I found the most memorable.
A note that you’ll want to download and run the Debugger Helper on any games you play here, or you’ll get weird results. Also, if any files have Japanese or weird characters in their names, rename the file without those characters or the files likely won’t run or be patchable.
I Wanna Challenge 100 Trials!!!– It’s lower down on the spreadsheet, but I’m putting it first because I think you’ll get the most enjoyment out of it before you get too skilled at fangames, if that makes sense. This is a 100 single-screen level that’s mostly a gentle introduction to fangames. If you play some more challenging ones and come back to this one, you might think it’s actually too gentle, which is valid (FlannelKat noted she was bored until the last 20 levels). The exception is Level 85, which IMO needed a checkpoint about ¾ of the way through (A second playthrough up to Level 85 has not changed my opinion on this). Still, I enjoyed this one a lot.
I Wanna Be the Octophobia– A fun, brief sampler of a bunch of microgenres of fangames. The main weakness is the final boss, which requires a small degree of mashing fire to quickly kill it. At some point, fangames moved toward giving bosses i-frames to remove mashing as a skill, but this one doesn’t have them.
I Wanna Go the Spook House– This is a bit more in the spirit of the original IWBTG, and it’s not actually very scary despite the title. The final boss is also inspired by Undertale, which is neat.
I Wanna Get the Rainbow Feather– A more explicitly structured “Sampler Platter” of IWBTG fangames. Your goal is to get a…Rainbow Feather. To do so, after a few screens, you go through a number of portals each themed around a subgenre of fangame—you have your “trap” world (Basically a high level of trolls you will die to on your first pass), your water world, your puzzle world, etc. The puzzle world in particular is fun to work through.
I Wanna Be the Strongest Fairy– BAKA, BAKA! BAKA, BAKA! BAKA, BAKA! (BAKA, BAKA!) BAKA, BAKA! BAKA, BAKA! BAKA, BAKA! (BAKA, BAKA!)
I Wanna Find A Test Player– This definitely stood out to me, though not entirely in a positive way. The actual “game” part is very well done, and presents some neat ideas/dynamic difficulty/etc. I was less of a fan of the “developer character” throughout the game, though it was certainly memorable. There’s also a bit at the end I thought was pretty neat.
I Wanna Be the Party– Of the bronze tier games, this most evoked original I Wanna Be the Guy: It is absolutely filled with traps (I counted 8 in one room). It’s also pretty short, so give it a shot anyway even if “Trap game” doesn’t sound like something you’ll enjoy. I also think it’s more enjoyable to “get got” if you know you’re in for that going in; given that, I wonder if I’d enjoy IWBTG more now…
I Wanna Escape Endless Nightmare– This one is the most Metroid-like, giving you power-ups you use to get through the various game worlds. While it fit the title, I wasn’t the biggest fan of the second loop, though I completed it regardless. The Metroid-like aspect of this drew me in, though.
I Wanna Conquer the Blow Game 3– I have no idea what some of these game titles are. Regardless, this one is almost a subversion of “trap games”. It’s light on proper traps, and quite heavy on what I’ve heard called “mischief” in non-IWBTG contexts. As with a lot of these games, I felt the end (In this case something of a boss rush) was the weakest part. Still recommended.
I Wanna Can’t Stop– This is less an “IWBTG fangame” than a “Mario Party fangame that happens to use one of the I Wanna Be the Engines”. Despite that, and despite another unique challenge, I had a lot of fun with it. What was that unique challenge? Well, the link here takes you to an English version of the game. However, the “All download links” in the spreadsheet where I grabbed the entire B-Side Bronze tier had the Japanese version instead—I didn’t realize an English version even existed until doing this writeup when I clicked the direct download link for the game on the spreadsheet. Not being able to read the game rules (Outside of numbers, from which I could guess when I had to score “X points in Y seconds”) added a Warioware-style element where I had to figure out what the games wanted me to do in addition to executing them. There is a game or two that’s effectively impossible without being able to read the language, but overall, that additional element might have made the game more fun for me.
There you are! Ten I Wanna Be the Guy fangames, most of which are fairly easy relative to the original game! Enjoy!
-EE